Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
the adviser logo
Broker

Industry veteran backs best interests duty

by Reporter6 minute read
Ben Kingsley

A leading broker has praised Commissioner Hayne’s recommendation to introduce a best interests duty for brokers, saying he will support it “til the cows come home”.

Speaking on an episode of The Smart Property Investment Show  the podcast of The Adviser’s sister title, Smart Property Investment  Ben Kingsley, broker and director at Empower Wealth and chair of the board of directors at the Property Investors Council of Australia, said he is in favour of the introduction of a best interests duty and test for brokers, as recommended by Commissioner Kenneth Hayne in his final report for the banking royal commission.

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

“I could show a customer through careful money management – and we go deep into cash flow movements every month for the next 40 or 50 years – that that borrower can safely borrow another $100,000. And let’s say instead of buying a $400,000 property, they bought a $500,000; they could be, if we have the same type of return, about $300,000 better off,” he explained.

“So, if I have a best interest test, [then] that says to me that I can’t advise my client – based on the analysis of the cashflow that I’ve done – that they shouldn’t push the envelope a little bit harder to borrow a little bit more.

Advertisement
Advertisement

“Whereas, if I went to [a] branch and they’ve got one servicing calculator, that one servicing calculator maxes them out at a certain point.”

The Empower Wealth director also warned of the adverse consequences of introducing a fee-for-service model – where the borrower pays a mortgage arrangement fee to brokers and lenders  saying that it will lead to “contraction in terms of the choices you have”.

This model was proposed by Commissioner Hayne as an alternative to the current lender-paid upfront and trail commission structure, which has been intensely scrutinised for being “conflicted”.

The idea, which was presented in the final royal commission report, sparked fears over the longevity of the mortgage broking industry and the impact on consumers, should such a drastic change be legislated.

Consumers might not be able to afford the fees attached to mortgage advice, resulting in the reduced ability to access the right loan products (including products from the smaller lenders), and those who are able to afford the fees could inherit significant costs that the banking sector previously absorbed.

For this reason, as Mr Kingsley suggested, the fee-for-service model may be a contradictory recommendation to the best interests duty.

Despite the government stating it would implement all of Commissioner Hayne’s recommendations, Prime Minister Scott Morrison showed hesitance towards the recommendation to eliminate lender-paid broker commissions, saying that he doesn’t want the broking sector to “wither on the vine and be strangled by regulation that would throw them out of business… [and] deny choice and competition in the banking system”.

“If there is one thing that we have learned through this process, it is that we need more competition. We need more options. We need more choices. Not fewer. And that is what the Treasurer and I are concerned about in terms of how we would go forward on that one recommendation [on broker remuneration],” the Prime Minister said.

Regarding the major political parties, Mr Kingsley said that the government’s initial response to adopt every recommendation is slowly trickling back.

He continued: “I suspect they are a little bit surprised by the groundswell of support for people in terms of using brokers because they came out before the royal commission.”

“Now, everyone’s been sort of backed into a corner, both Liberal and Labor.”

Listen to the full episode of The Smart Property Investment Show here.

[Related: Banking royal commission calls for best interests duty]

Industry veteran backs best interests duty
benkingsley ta
TheAdviser logo
benkingsley ta

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today

MORE FROM THE ADVISER

Glen Lees

Connective announces record settlement figures

Mortgage aggregator Connective has revealed that its brokers settled a record $95.5 billion across its residential,...

READ MORE
charles grover outfund ta zgvq5o

New SME lender launches into broker channel

A new fintech lender, Outfund, is ramping up for growth through the broker channel after having completed a capital...

READ MORE
david bailey afg ta l8ozkr

AFG’s bottom line hit by Volt closure

The ASX-listed company, Australian Finance Group Ltd (ASX: AFG) has confirmed it is set to deliver “strong...

READ MORE
magazine
Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more