the adviser logo

Impact of technology on jobs ‘grossly overestimated’

by Jessica Yun5 minute read
Impact of technology

There is no need to fear the prospect of mass unemployment caused by artificial intelligence and machine learning, according to AMP Capital.

In an Econosights note, AMP Capital senior economist Diana Mousina argued that new technologies have never created “mass rise in unemployment” and the notion that automation would take over jobs had been “grossly overestimated”.

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

“There is no need to fear technology,” Ms Mousina said.

“Technology is a long-run factor that has been helping to keep a lid on inflation.


“Investors should not be worried about mass unemployment across the advanced economies caused by technological disruptions,” she said.

Statistics in a “widely referenced report by Frey and Osborne in 2013” had floated the idea that nearly half of jobs in America were at risk of “computerisation”, but in reality, only about 9 per cent of jobs across the OECD were susceptible to automation.

“In net terms, technology hasn’t and isn’t currently destroying jobs,” Ms Mousina said. 

However, it was creating a phenomenon of “distortion in the labour market” called “job polarisation”.

“Job polarisation refers to a decline in middle-skill jobs while the share of low-skill and high-skill jobs increases,” Ms Mousina explained.

Two driving factors behind job polarisation were the impact of technology (that is, machines carrying out tasks previously done by humans) and the movement of jobs overseas.

Ms Mousina said: “Middle-skill jobs tend to be more susceptible to displacement by technology because jobs in that group tend to be routine-based manual or cognitive tasks (e.g., routine manual jobs include construction, transportation and production jobs; and routine cognitive jobs include sales and office occupations), which means they can be learned and replicated by machines.

“High-skill jobs tend to be harder to replace by machines because they are non-routine and cognitive-based (e.g., management and professional jobs), which requires human judgment and expertise.

“At the other end of the spectrum, low-skill jobs are usually non-routine manual tasks (e.g., service-based jobs that are related to assisting others like in cleaning and gardening), which are also difficult to replace by a machine.”

The advance of technology would not replace humans, but rather see roles evolve as well as “allow productivity gains and cost benefits for firms that will allow a change in tasks for occupations”.

“Technology can make humans more creative, improve productivity for the economy (that has been lagging over recent years) as well as improve living standards (e.g., usage of new technologies in medicine) across the global economy, particularly in developing countries.”

The senior economist concluded: “But middle-skill jobs and incomes will continue to be at risk by technology, which is likely to create continued angst in these population groups.”

[Related: Predictive machine learning could come to mortgages]

Impact of technology on jobs ‘grossly overestimated’
TheAdviser logo

James Mitchell

James Mitchell


James Mitchell has over eight years’ experience as a financial reporter and is the editor of Wealth and Wellness at Momentum Media.


You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today


Anja Pannek CEO PLAN

Anja Pannek named MFAA CEO

The board of the Mortgage & Finance Association of Australia (MFAA) has confirmed that Anja Pannek will be the...

mike felton mfaa ta jdayl5

Aggregator heads reflect on Mike Felton’s legacy

Following on the news that Mike Felton is to retire next month and step down as chief executive of the Mortgage &...

melanie kiely afg ta mzh8zm

AFG non-executive director steps down from board

Australian Finance Group Ltd (AFG) has advised that Melanie Kiely will be stepping down from the AFG board to...

Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more