the adviser logo

ANZ sees ‘merit’ in best interest duty

by Reporter6 minute read
anz bank merit best interest duty brokers

Applying best interest obligations to brokers could help preserve the integrity of the third-party channel, according to ANZ CEO Shayne Elliott.

In his opening address to the Productivity Commission (PC) on Tuesday, 6 March, Mr Elliott claimed that a “best interest duty” applied to the broking space could enhance consumer protection. 

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

“About half of our mortgages originate from brokers. As such, while we don’t own a broker network, we believe the integrity of the channel is critical,” the CEO said.

“The Productivity Commission has made some recommendations concerning brokers. We see merit in enhancing the consumer protections in this space.


“A best interests duty could support the existing law to promote consumer interests when receiving help from a broker.”

In draft recommendation 8.1 of its report, the PC called for the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to impose a “clear legal duty” on lender-owned aggregators, which should also “apply to mortgage brokers working under them”.

The ANZ CEO told commissioners that despite the absence of a legal duty of care, consumers may be under the impression that such obligations already exist.

Mr Elliott added: “I imagine that a lot of people think that the broker does have a duty of care to them. I imagine that when mums and dads walk into a [brokerage], they assume that is the case.

“You may go as far as to say that they have a best interest duty as well — I don’t know — but I think there is an expectation.

“[I] think FOFA [Future of Financial Advice reforms] and others have probably raised that expectation and say well if that’s the rule for a financial planner, we assume it is for a broker, but I think it’s important to go and ask consumers and their representatives.”

ANZ on fees for service

Further, PC commissioner Peter Harris inquired about the feasibility of a fixed fee model as opposed to a volume-based commission paid to brokers.

“I have the impression that perhaps a fee is a better proposition. The question might be, should it be paid by the consumer, or should it still be paid by the bank?” Mr Harris said.

In response, the ANZ chief said that there is “absolute merit” in exploring such a model, and he pointed to the use of a fixed fee structure in Europe.

“The reality is, today, in an open, highly competitive market, [we have been] taken down a commission-based structure,” Mr Elliott said.

“There’s an understandable logic to that given that there’s an alignment between the commission and the volume obviously driving revenue to the bank.

“I think there’s merit in looking at a fee-based structure. I can’t imagine [that] it would evolve naturally — that would require some intervention. Either as an industry or through regulation would be my guess.”

ANZ on financial planners entering the credit space

The major bank chief also commented on calls from the PC to introduce financial planners into the credit space.

Mr Elliott highlighted the difference between the two services and noted that there are no restrictions on financial planners obtaining a broking license.

“To my knowledge, there’s nothing stopping people from doing that today, so if I have a financial planning license, I can go and get a broking license — there’s nothing prohibiting that, but for some reason, that has not evolved,” the CEO said.

“Our view from experience, and just looking at the products, they are different and our customers think about them in a very different way.

“There’s an old adage: wealth products are sold and mortgages are bought. People think about them very differently; they think about who they go to for that advice.”

[Related: Russell defends trail, slams calls for ‘fees for service’]

ANZ sees ‘merit’ in best interest duty
TheAdviser logo


You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today


mark lewis fast ta llosc4

In Memoriam: Mark Lewis, 1963–2022

Mark Lewis passed away on Saturday (13 August). Mr Lewis was a well-known identity in the third-party broker...

anthony waldron mortgage choice ta ithtxm

Broker expertise key for securing right loan: Mortgage Choice

The data, which is derived from a June survey of 1,002 broker customers and conducted by Honeycomb Strategy,...

Mark Bouris new ifa

Brokers need to focus on the ‘value-add’: Mark Bouris

With competition among brokers increasing as the number of brokers rises – coupled with the fact that fewer...

Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more