Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
the adviser logo
Broker

Robo-advice, AI flagged as major threats to broker proposition

by Charbel Kadib6 minute read
Deloitte

Mortgage industry representatives have named robo-advice and artificial intelligence as emerging threats to the broker proposition.

Global consultancy firm Deloitte has published its annual Australian Mortgage report, which seeks to provide insight into industry expectations for the year ahead.

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

Deloitte asked 10 industry executives for their take on emerging issues in the home loan space, including what they would consider the ‘major disruptive forces’ to the broker channel over the next three years.

According to the Deloitte, 40 per cent of respondents — which included representatives from lenders, mortgage aggregators and fintechs — flagged robo-advice and artificial intelligence (AI) as a major challenge to the broker proposition.

Advertisement
Advertisement

However, Mortgage Choice CEO Susan Mitchell, who participated in Deloitte’s roundtable, said robo-advice and AI would complement, rather than threaten the broker offering.

“I actually consider robo-advice as a tool to be used by a broker rather than competing against brokers,” she said.

“It may be a different kind of broker than we see today, but I don’t believe a robo-advice structure necessarily means there is no broker involved.

“I think there is a big opportunity in the future for a robo-advice structure where a simpler transaction flows straight through the broking process to a lender and on through to settlement. Whereas a more complex transaction, or one where the customer requires more information, may kick out the process and require a face-to-face meeting to complete.”

Ms Mitchell added: “The reality is that consumers are becoming more complicated.”

Other factors identified by respondents as potential challenges to the broker proposition included scrutiny over broker remuneration (20 per cent), a generational shift in the industry (20 per cent), digital broking platforms (10 per cent), and customer preferences for face-to-face engagement (10 per cent).

However, Loan Market’s executive chairman, Sam White — also part of the roundtable — flagged another potential challenge to the broker proposition in 2020, citing customer service complacency.

“One of the things that’s not on the list of disruptive forces is that the broker starts to take his or her position of trust with the consumer for granted,” he said. “I think that’s the real danger.”

Mr White warned that white-labelling among aggregators could undermine the traditional strengths of the broker proposition.

“I think there’s a danger in aggregators thinking they can flog their own product through this channel without thinking, he said.

“This will dilute the fundamental value that brokers bring of ‘putting my customer first’.

“If brokers lose that, or it goes away and gets replaced by something more efficient that delivers better value to customers, then that is the demise of the broker.”

However, the Loan Market head noted that the newly legislated best interests duty would help ensure that brokers continue delivering good outcomes for consumers.  

Despite acknowledging challenges to the broker proposition, David Harrys, head of product, partnerships and bank experience at RACQ, said brokers would play an increasingly critical role in the mortgage market as established lenders roll-back their branch networks.  

“All the major banks are retreating from their direct distribution models because they realise they can’t compete with brokers,” he said.

“If they believed they could compete with them, they’d be investing in those channels.

“For most people that run a distribution model, the biggest argument they have with their lender is how many applications they can take this week. How many interviews? That’s business development.”

He concluded: “If you run your own business as brokers do, they have to have those conversations, because if they don’t, they don’t exist. They have to service their customer base.”

 

Are you interested in the issues shaping the roles of mortgage and finance brokers? Don’t miss your chance to hear about all the big ideas for the year ahead, and gain the tools you need to position your business for growth and prosperity. Book your ticket to the Better Business Summit today.  

[Related: Best interest duty won’t be ‘shock to system’]  

Robo-advice, AI flagged as major threats to broker proposition
deloitte ta
TheAdviser logo
deloitte ta

Charbel Kadib

Charbel Kadib

AUTHOR

Charbel Kadib is the news editor on The Adviser and Mortgage Business.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today

MORE FROM THE ADVISER

mark pesce futurist ajxjkn

Automation is changing, not replacing, the role of finance brokers

On Thursday (4 August), the Australian Financial Review (AFR) ran a story with the headline: “Finance brokers top...

READ MORE
des hang carbar zaheer jappie carclarity ta qtvnqr

CarClarity confirms partnership with car subscription platform

Established in March 2020, CarClairty is a finance platform that connects car buyers with more than 30 different...

READ MORE
anthony albanese profile ta vtpifc

Further grants confirmed for flood survivors, $47m pledged

According to a statement released by the federal government, the Back Home grant will be made available to impacted...

READ MORE
magazine
Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more