the adviser logo

Credit scrutiny tougher on broker-originated loans

by Tas Bindi6 minute read

There is a “widening gap” between the funding that could potentially be obtained by borrowers who approach banks directly and those who go through a broker, a brokerage director has lamented. 

Speaking to The Adviser, founder and director of Loan Saver, Colin Kidd, said he has observed a noticeable risk being borne by brokers not completing detailed expenditure analysis, as well as a difference between the way expenses are obtained by brokers and lenders. 

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

Brokers are able to match the expenditure requirements of the lender, but the risk associated with the analysis would remain with the broker, according to Mr Kidd.

To eliminate the compliance risk, the Loan Saver director said brokers need to obtain substantial detail about expenditure using bank statements than what customers would be required to provide if they approached the banks directly. 


“A signed budget is in no way acceptable for an expenditure analysis,” the Loan Saver director said. 

Reflecting on recent dealings with lenders, Mr Kidd said that there have been cases where he has included a significant one-off expense in the required analysis, explaining in the notes that it is a one-off expense related to launching a new business, but the lender said the new small-business owner’s expenditure was too high to pass its serviceability assessment. This is despite the customer otherwise having a “clean” credit record. 

“Each lender we discussed the file with indicated that they would follow the expenditure noted on the statement of position. So, even after evidencing the singular expense, they would use the full amount,” the Loan Saver director said. 

“For compliance purposes, including this as a before and after expense would still result in a decline based on servicing.”

Mr Kidd continued: “If the clients go directly to the lender, they don’t need to do the expenditure analysis [using] bank statements. They’ll accept the client’s statement of position and the loan will go through.”

He has noticed that some borrowers have been able to obtain a loan directly through the bank that they could not through the broker. 

If clients have a better chance at getting a loan directly than through a broker, this would impact the channel they choose to use when seeking finance, according to the Loan Saver director. 

“You have to [demonstrate] that it’s not an ongoing expense, so you have to wait three months. But during that period of time, the clients are going directly to the bank and getting approved,” he said.

“So, bank managers are writing loans that were declined through brokers. Theres a widening gap between what can be funded through the lender and what can be funded through the broker.”

Further, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has been assessing historical cases based on today’s credit policy requirements around expenditure, according to Mr Kidd. 

“AFCA is retrospectively applying today’s assessment criteria to loans written prior to the GFC. This is obviously a cause of concern,” the Loan Saver director said. 

“Brokers that are writing large volumes are at enormous risk of litigation.”

The Adviser has reached out to AFCA to clarify how it assesses historical cases.

[Related: Credit crackdown to offset boost from rate cuts]

Credit scrutiny tougher on broker-originated loans
bank statement ta
TheAdviser logo
bank statement ta

Tas Bindi

Tas Bindi


Tas Bindi is the features editor for The Adviser magazine. 


You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today


mark lewis fast ta llosc4

In Memoriam: Mark Lewis, 1963–2022

Mark Lewis passed away on Saturday (13 August). Mr Lewis was a well-known identity in the third-party broker...

anthony waldron mortgage choice ta ithtxm

Broker expertise key for securing right loan: Mortgage Choice

The data, which is derived from a June survey of 1,002 broker customers and conducted by Honeycomb Strategy,...

Mark Bouris new ifa

Brokers need to focus on the ‘value-add’: Mark Bouris

With competition among brokers increasing as the number of brokers rises – coupled with the fact that fewer...

Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more