the adviser logo

ANZ CEO chimes in on broker debate

by Charbel Kadib6 minute read
Shayne Elliott

ANZ CEO Shayne Elliott has responded to calls for broking reform during a parliamentary committee hearing in Canberra.

Appearing before the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Economics, ANZ CEO Shayne Elliott issued a warning regarding “unintended consequences” that may arise off the back of broking reforms.

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

Deputy chair of the committee and Labor MP Matthew Thistlethwaite asked Mr Elliott whether he believes brokers should charge fees for service to address what he considered conflicted remuneration practices.

However, in response, Mr Elliott joined Westpac CEO Brian Hartzer in highlighting the role that brokers play in the market and noted the work of the Combined Industry Forum (CIF).


“We [ANZ] think brokers play a really important role in the market. More than half of all mortgages that are originated in Australia come through brokers, so consumers like the service,” Mr Elliott said.

“I accept that there is the potential for conflicts of interests in remuneration and we’ve moved away from volume-based commissions.”

The ANZ CEO said that remuneration reform is “worthy of discussion” but warned: “My only caution is that no system is perfect, and any system will have potentially unintended consequences”.

He continued: “I think the [broking industry and regulators] can sit down and consider improvements to that model, but as of today, we think they perform a valuable role that consumers actually prefer and choose to increase the amount of business they give to brokers every year.”

Best interest duty

However, when asked if a “best interest duty” should be imposed on brokers, Mr Elliott questioned why such a duty was not already in place.

“I imagine that most people that go to a broker think they do have a best interest duty,” Mr Elliott said.

“Mums and dads imagine it’s true, so I think there’s an absolutely valid argument to say that they should have some obligations in that area.”

Mr Thistlethwaite, an opposition MP, suggested that the government needed to introduce legislation, alleging that brokers don’t work in the best interests of their clients.

“The notion of a broker, in its purest form, is a good one,” the Labor MP said.

“Someone that has expertise will use that expertise to shop around on behalf of their client to get them the best deal. But it appears based on the evidence that has come out of the [financial services] royal commission that it doesnt always happen.”

Mr Thistlethwaite continued: “Banks have tried to establish relationships with brokers using various means of bonuses, holidays and the like so that they will have an incentive to refer people to that bank.

“Thats the reason why were in this mess, isnt it, and why we have to be considering best interest duties. 

“We would all hope that they would act in the best interest of the customer, but thats the problem — they dont, and thats where we have to step in and regulate.” 

However, in response, Mr Elliott said: “I think it can be a problem; Im not sure its the problem. I think that most brokers are decent, honourable people who do the right thing for customers.

“Most brokers have a lifetime relationship with those clients, not just transactional, but I do think there can be improvements there around that, [and] I dont doubt that for a second.”

ANZ fired 200 staff for misconduct

Mr Elliott also told parliamentary committee members that the major bank terminated the contracts of approximately 200 staff as a direct result of misconduct.

“Where there have been consequences, they have often involved pay cuts and people leaving the bank,” Mr Elliott said.

“In the last year, we have dismissed around 200 people across the group for misconduct. Not all of that is related to the events covered by the royal commission. Some of those were senior executives.”

Mr Elliott added that of the 200 staff dismissed by ANZ, “a handful” or approximately 10 senior executives that reported directly to the CEO had been dismissed for misconduct.

[Related: ‘Tricky’ broker model ‘mostly works well’: Westpac CEO]

ANZ CEO chimes in on broker debate
shayne elliot anz
TheAdviser logo
shayne elliot anz

Charbel Kadib

Charbel Kadib


Charbel Kadib is the news editor on The Adviser and Mortgage Business.


You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today


Boomer home loans

New non-bank lender enters administration

Specialist lender Boomer Home Loans, named in reference to its target age demographic (Baby Boomers; those born in...

royden dvaz assetline capital ta fh2e1i

New national head of sales recruited at Assetline Capital

Royden D'Vaz, formerly head of distribution with the non-bank mortgage lender MKM, has been recruited as Assetline...

john maxwell oscar zhuo ta sthnmq

Uptick Marketing launches

Uptick Marketing (Uptick) aims to work in partnership with brokers to assist the third-party channel in “closing...

Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more