the adviser logo

Broker commissions ‘the high-water mark’ for disclosure

by James Mitchell6 minute read

An ACL holder believes that upfront and trail commissions need to “make a comeback”, rather than be vilified, as they create clarity and choice in the mortgage market.

Wealthy & Wise executive chairman Scott Heathwood runs a national wealth and lending group that offers financial planning, accounting, tax and mortgage broking services.

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

He believes that the malignant rhetoric surrounding commissions in financial advice, and now mortgage broking, was originated in Canberra by “feckless morons” who needed a scapegoat for their incompetence.

“Sadly, the complexity of the financial sector was overblown in the minds of the legislators and this gave rise to the wholesale slaughter of the old and effective distribution system,” Mr Heathwood told The Adviser. “The retail financial services sector is very vanilla at its core.


“It became clear during this passage of time that the advisory process hadn’t improved and so the feckless morons in Canberra needed a scapegoat — enter commission and conflicted remuneration. What a quaint way to lay the blame squarely at the feet of the advisory business.

“Commission was now the great ‘bogeyman’, wow, a double whammy for suppliers; commission was the root of all evil and removing it lowered costs.”

Mr Heathwood’s comments come after ASIC chair James Shipton last week said that he has been “surprised” that there has been “reluctance, and often resistance, to addressing conflicts, especially those embedded in remuneration”, and highlighted the regulator’s 2017 broker remuneration report.

Mr Shipton pointed out how ASIC’s review highlighted the “desirability of removing at least some of the remuneration-related conflicts in this sector”.

Broker remuneration has been under intense scrutiny, with some suggesting that commissions should be scrapped altogether and replaced with a fee for service.

But according to Mr Heathwood, commission-driven selling is “the high-water mark for disclosure”.

“It creates clarity, it creates choice, it encourages the customer to seek other opinions, but most importantly, it divides the sector into component parts and creates the opportunity for the truly independent advisory professionals to emerge on their terms,” the executive chairman said.

“Retail financial products are simple in their nature. Selling investments and insurance should be no different to selling home loans or cars or anything else.

“Stock brokers have and are doing it still. Let the brands compete and do their best, but allow the breathing space for impartial advice to co-exist rigorously; a profession will emerge because when you integrate financial products, you then need advice. Until this issue is addressed, it will remain smoke and mirrors.”

According to Mr Heathwood, trail and upfront commissions are not the enemy, saying: “They are paid from the manufacturer, forms part of their marketing and business acquisition budget, does not increase the cost to the buyer, is fully disclosed to the customer, lowers fees to clients and underwrites a competitive marketplace from which we know all innovation is derived.

“The time for commission to make a comeback is now; the internet has never made the market more transparent.”

[Related: Major brokerage calls for remuneration reform]

Broker commissions ‘the high-water mark’ for disclosure
business people discussion ta
TheAdviser logo
business people discussion ta

James Mitchell

James Mitchell


James Mitchell has over eight years’ experience as a financial reporter and is the editor of Wealth and Wellness at Momentum Media.


You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today


daniel tuttlebee resimac asset fInance ta l27zun

Resimac takes controlling stake in Sonder

Resimac Asset Finance has expanded its acquisition stake in equipment finance business Sonder Equipment Finance...

asic ta 2

ASIC seeks ‘common-sense solutions’ to breach reporting

The Australian Securities & Investments Commission (ASIC) has committed to “improving” the operation of the...

andrew mills homestart ta htfetw

HomeStart drops graduate loan deposit to 2%

HomeStart Finance, a non-bank lender backed by the South Australian state government, has lowered the deposit hurdle...

Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more