Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.

Clawback system ‘needs to change’

louisa sanghera ta louisa sanghera ta
Hannah Dowling 6 minute read

The clawback system, as solidified in new legislation, is “completely unfair” on brokers says Sydney-based broker and Zippy Financial director Louisa Sanghera.

In light of the Financial Sector Reform (Hayne Royal Commission Response - Protecting Consumers [2019 Measures]) Bill 2019 being passed in both houses of Parliament earlier this month, Zippy Financial director Louisa Sanghera spoke out against the setting of a two-year commission clawback period within the legislation.

Ms Sanghera stated that under the new legislation, brokers may be “left out of pocket” should a client choose to change lenders within the first two years of their loan term. 

“[Brokers] have no control over what clients decide to do once the transaction is completed, yet, we end up essentially working for free if they change lenders or repay their loans within the first year or two,” Ms Sanghera said.

Advertisement
Advertisement

“In what other industry is it alright to essentially not get paid for work that you have successfully completed because of something that is completely out of your control?

“The whole system is wrong and needs to change.”

Ms Sanghera stressed that neither the broker nor the customer should be penalised for changing the terms of the loan, or switching lenders, in the first two years of taking out a new loan.

“Most clients stay with their lender for the long-term, but if they decide to refinance or perhaps repay the mortgage because of an inheritance quickly that is their absolute right to do so,” she said.

“Why should brokers, which are generally small businesses, be financially penalised for decisions that we have no control over and why does the government seem to think this is appropriate?"

PROMOTED CONTENT


Ms Sanghera also stated that the clawback claims process is flawed, as it does not allow for brokers to dispute the decision.

“[T]he system is not transparent as lenders simply notify us of clawbacks but aren’t required to provide evidence,” she said.

“I just can’t understand why the industry allows all brokers to have to pay back the money they have earned if the client does the wrong thing by the broker and, ultimately, the lender?”

Ms Sanghera stated that the harm of clawbacks on brokers, many of whom operate their own small businesses, is significant.

The threat of clawbacks causes cash flow uncertainty for smaller brokerages and sole traders, and the only beneficiary of the system appears to be the big banks, according to the Zippy Financial director.

“Clawbacks were introduced prior to the royal commission and have always been bad policy in my opinion,” Ms Sanghera said.

“Now it is set to become law with the only beneficiaries being big banks.”

She concluded: “Brokers are generally small businesses and it is completely unfair that we are seemingly expected to work for free.”

[Related: Best Interests Duty Bill formally passed]

Clawback system ‘needs to change’
louisa sanghera ta
TheAdviser logo

If you’re feeling overworked and overwhelmed in this fast-paced mortgage market, it’s time to make some changes, and the Business Accelerator Program can help! Work smarter, not harder, in 2022 and beyond, visit the website here to secure your ticket.

louisa sanghera ta
Hannah Dowling

Hannah Dowling

Hannah Dowling is a journalist for The Adviser and Mortgage Business.

Prior to joining Momentum Media, Hannah worked as a content producer for a podcast catering to property investors. She also spent six years working in the real estate sector at a local agency. 

Email Hannah at: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

 

 

more from the adviser
Beau Bertoli Greg Moshal 863x385jpg

Breaking News

Prospa squares up against banks, expands SME loan

The ASX-listed lender has flagged a new “all-in-one” business...

small business owner ta

Breaking News

Business credit demand bounces back in NSW

Data from the initial days of NSW reopening after lockdown has sh...

suburb

Breaking News

Hot Property: The biggest property headlines from the week 18-22 October

The weekly round-up of the biggest news stories from across Momen...