Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.

Stiffer penalties flagged as alternative to BID

lend money ta lend money ta
Charbel Kadib 5 minute read

The industry should focus on “preventing and penalising” broker misconduct rather than imposing a new legal obligation, the Law Society of NSW has said.

In its submission to Treasury, released following the publication of the draft best interests duty bill, the Law Society of NSW has questioned the practicality of the proposed reforms.

The association raised concerns regarding the lack of guidance around the definition of best interests in clause 158LA of the draft bill, which was left unchanged in the revised bill tabled in Parliament last month.

“There is no definition or guidance on what ‘best interests’ means in clause 158LA of the bill,” the Law Society noted in its submission.


“We suggest that further guidance be provided.”

The group cast doubt over the applicability of the clause in the provision of credit assistance by brokers, which, it noted, do not have access to the full suite of products offered to borrowers in the marketplace.

“On a plain English reading, brokers will need to seek out the best possible option for a consumer in all the circumstances,” the association added.

“The practical impact of the requirement may be somewhat artificial in any case, as brokers generally do not have access to all lenders and all products, and brokers are likely to still conduct their analysis based on their lender panel.”

As a result, the Law Society has proposed an alternative to the best interests duty, which it claimed would incentivise brokers to deliver good outcomes for borrowers without having to commit to complying with a new legal obligation.    


According to the association, the industry could consider imposing stiffer penalties for breaches of existing responsible lending obligations under the National Consumer Credit Protections Act (NCCP).  

“We acknowledge that the government has announced that it will implement recommendation 1.2 of the final report of the financial services royal commission,” the Law Society stated.

“In our view, however, reforms could be made in the industry with a focus on preventing and penalising broker misconduct i.e. conduct to the consumer’s detriment, rather than simply creating a new positive statutory duty.”

Under existing arrangements, a breach of NCCP incurs a maximum penalty of 2,000 penalty units, while a breach of the government’s proposed best interests duty would incur a penalty of 5,000 penalty units.

More guidance around how the best interests duty applies in practice is expected to be released by ASIC before the end of the year, which, stakeholders have said, would be “almost as crucial as what’s in the legislation”.

[Related: White label revenue at risk, warns NAB]

Stiffer penalties flagged as alternative to BID
lend money ta
TheAdviser logo

If you’re feeling overworked and overwhelmed in this fast-paced mortgage market, it’s time to make some changes, and the Business Accelerator Program can help! Work smarter, not harder, in 2022 and beyond, visit the website here to secure your ticket.

lend money ta
Charbel Kadib

Charbel Kadib

Charbel Kadib is the news editor on The Adviser and Mortgage Business.

Before joining the team in 2017, Charbel completed internships with public relations agency Fifty Acres, and the Department of Communications and the Arts.

Email Charbel on: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


more from the adviser
Beau Bertoli Greg Moshal 863x385jpg

Breaking News

Prospa squares up against banks, expands SME loan

The ASX-listed lender has flagged a new “all-in-one” business...

small business owner ta

Breaking News

Business credit demand bounces back in NSW

Data from the initial days of NSW reopening after lockdown has sh...


Breaking News

Hot Property: The biggest property headlines from the week 18-22 October

The weekly round-up of the biggest news stories from across Momen...