Major bank CEO defends brokers

Major bank CEO defends brokers

Protecting people Protecting people
Charbel Kadib Comments 19 — 3 minute read

Shutting down the broking industry would be “extreme” and would have a “dramatic” impact on the Australian economy, a major bank CEO has said in response to a suggestion from a parliamentarian that the broker channel could be “closed”.

In his appearance before the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Economics, NAB CEO Andrew Thorburn highlighted the contribution of the broking industry, in response to a question from Liberal MP Jason Falinski asking whether he was concerned the broking industry could be “closed” due to perceived issues identified by the financial services royal commission.

Mr Falinski questioned whether issues raised by the commission (regarding misaligned incentives and alleged “misrepresentation” in mortgage applications) could shut the industry down.

The MP asked: “Are you not worried that out of the royal commission, where there has been a lot of pressure being put on incentives for brokers, for example, and a lot of claims that they have been the prime source of misrepresenting people’s incomes and expenses, that this is a particular channel that might get closed?”

However, in response, Mr Thorburn said: “Closing it down would be dramatic [and] extreme, given that over 50 per cent of volume coming through banks comes through brokers.


“Those brokers are, in many cases [licensed professionals] running a small business, so the impact on the economy and their livelihood would be dramatic.”

Mr Thorburn added that the bank is ultimately responsible for validating a borrower’s home loan application.

“We expect brokers to do certain things when they take details from customers, to pass that in full to us. We make the decision ultimately as to whether we will extend credit to the customer,” the CEO said.

“We look at their income, we definitely go through, in great detail, their expenditure to make sure they can afford it.”

He continued: “We require the customer, even though the broker is dealing with them, to be able to pay principal and interest back, even if theyre getting interest-only, and we require them to be able to afford 7.25 per cent [interest rate] per annum as a minimum, even though theyll be paying a lot less in todays rates.

“I do think we have a lot of checks and balances in that process, and I do think while the broker market needs to evolve, its playing an important role.”

Further, Mr Thorburn noted the competitive impact that the broking industry has had on the mortgage market, pointing to role it played in reducing interest rates when the industry emerged in the 1990s.

The NAB CEO also acknowledged the role that brokers play in helping clients navigate through the complexities of the mortgage market, making reference to the “blizzard” of home loan products offered by lenders.

However, echoing sentiments made by ANZ CEO Shayne Elliott, and Westpac CEO Brian Hartzer, Mr Thorburn said that there “needs to be some changes” to the broker model.

When asked by deputy chair of the committee and Labor MP Matthew Thistlethwaite whether the industry should move to a fees-for-service model, and if FOFA should be extended to brokers, Mr Thorburn called for greater clarity surround the payment of commissions but noted that the industry is already investigating the matter.

“Increasingly they’re [brokers] becoming more licensed and more professional, but I do think when the Sedgewick report was done, there was a conversation about [whether] they should be paid an upfront fee for a simple and a complex loan,” Mr Thorburn said.

“Should we make it clearer when we pay a trail to them? Obviously, thats disclosed, but what they need to do for that, and I think those things are under serious investigation right now by our bank and also by the industry itself.

“We havent got to the end of that process, but I think, in short, there needs to be some changes in those areas.”

[Related: ANZ CEO chimes in on broker debate]

Major bank CEO defends brokers
TheAdviser logo
Charbel Kadib

Charbel Kadib

Charbel Kadib is a journalist on the mortgages titles at Momentum Media.

Before joining the team in 2017, Charbel held roles with public relations agency Fifty Acres, and the Department of Communications and the Arts. 

Charbel graduated from the University of Notre Dame Australia with a Bachelor of Arts (Politics & Journalism).

more from the adviser
Fee-for-service not an ‘equitable’ model

It’s currently inconceivable that a fee-for-service model could...

Non-major warns of banning broker commissions

A Queensland-based bank has publicly defended broker commissions,...

Lender launches new mortgage products

The Bank of Sydney has launched a new basic mortgage product for ...