CBA CEO Matt Comyn has declined to single out brokers over suspected home loan fraud, telling a parliamentary hearing that lenders face different patterns of suspicious activity.
Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) chief executive Matt Comyn has declined to single out mortgage brokers over suspected home loan fraud, telling a parliamentary hearing that lenders face different patterns of suspicious activity and need better access to reliable information to verify applications.
Appearing before the House of Representatives standing committee on economics in Canberra on Friday (13 November), Comyn outlined CBA’s detection and reporting processes, placing the issue within a broader discussion of technology-enabled financial crime.
Asked about suspected fraudulently obtained mortgages, including loans allegedly supported by AI-generated documents, he described technology as an increasingly significant factor across several threats facing banks.
“At any point in time, as whilst banks have existed, there’s a pot of money people seek to extract it. I think, as I’ve said in many other areas, technology is increasingly playing a role, whether it’s in cyber, in scams, in fraud,” he said.
However, Comyn resisted narrowing the discussion to mortgage brokers, explaining that the matter reported publicly involved a pattern CBA had identified.
“I wouldn’t narrow it in the way that you did to mortgage brokers; I think there are, at any time, there are different, perhaps typologies or cohorts of customers where the one that was inevitably, or was reported externally, was where we detected a pattern,” he said.
His response contrasted with the emphasis placed on the broker channel by other major bank leaders during the hearings.
Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (ANZ) chief executive Nuno Matos claimed that most mortgage fraud identified in his bank’s review had come through brokers, while Westpac chief executive Anthony Miller linked increasingly sophisticated mortgage fraud to alleged broker involvement.
Comyn did not provide a total number of suspected fraudulently obtained mortgages during the exchange, despite being asked to do so.
The wider scrutiny followed February reporting that CBA had alerted authorities to potentially fraudulent mortgages worth up to $1 billion, involving both broker-originated lending and its introducer program.
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) subsequently confirmed that it was making compliance inquiries.
Subsequent reporting has placed suspected exposure across Australia’s five largest banks at around $4 billion.
Verification and information sharing underpin CBA’s response
Comyn distinguished the initial identification of irregularities from findings of fraud, and outlined how CBA investigated suspicious activity.
“We suspected them as irregularities, and without getting into the semantics about the difference between irregularities and fraud, we started investigating them. We reported it to the regulators, the regulators shared that with other financial institutions,” he said.
“In terms of external sources, we look at credit bureaus in and of themselves, and we see these sorts of things all the time, and we’re constantly looking to respond to that, and both strengthen our controls, but also play an important role, hopefully, across the broader sector.”
Earlier reporting on the CBA matter included allegations that accountants had supplied false income documents, some reportedly created using AI, underscoring the range of participants and verification processes under scrutiny.
Comyn said stronger access to authoritative information could help lenders validate material supplied to them, while stressing the need for privacy safeguards.
“One of the elements to reduce it is that you need a source of truth, whether that’s a company director database that ASIC has, and there’s obviously data elements that are important,” he said.
“There are certain events which are high indicators, and being able to get access to some of that data under the appropriate controls and privacy constraints would certainly help to validate the information that we’re being shown or provided.”
Arrears expected to rise through most of 2027
Beyond fraud, Comyn warned that mortgage stress would continue building, after CBA’s September-quarter update showed its 90-day arrears rate had reached 0.80 per cent.
Asked about the increase, he said borrowers remaining overdue for longer accounted for much of the gap between the current rate and its long-term average.
“It also includes both a number of new customers that are in arrears or 90 days overdue, as well as how long they’re staying in arrears, and so actually a bigger contributor to the 10 or 15 basis point rise is people spending more time in that 90-day section,” Comyn said.
“It’s not all flow of new customers that are falling behind on their mortgages.”
Comyn also set out an extended period of expected deterioration when pressed on the outlook moving forward.
“I would expect that the arrears rate would gradually trend up over the course of at least most of calendar year 2027,” he said.
“I think that the outlook for interest rates is certainly higher than it has been for the last decade, and that’s putting real pressure on households. Particularly, Australia is a country of higher household debt with variable rate mortgages.”
Investors retreat as the application mix shifts
Discussing lending demand following the May federal budget, Comyn said applications had fallen approximately 15 per cent, with investors accounting disproportionately for the decline.
“Application volumes were approximately 15 per cent down following the budget, and there were slightly different sort of time intervals, and it is stabilising now. It is disproportionately a reduction in investor, but that trend has largely continued,” he said.
He said that first home buyers (FHB) had increased their share of applications, although cautioned that their application volumes were lower.
“On a relative basis, I think it would still be down on first home buyers, but a lot less down because they now represent 29 per cent of share of applications,” he said.
“For first home buyers as a proportion if you think about applications in the month of October, they’re basically double versus 12 months ago, it’s 14.8 per cent to 28.5 per cent, investors have roughly halved from 44 per cent to 22 per cent.”
Other owner-occupiers also accounted for a larger proportion, although the overall pool of applications was smaller.
“Then owner-occupier ex first home buyer is 49 per cent, versus 41 per cent, so there’s a marked shift,” he said.
Asked whether the government’s property tax changes were achieving their stated objective of evening the playing field between FHBs and investors, Comyn offered a qualified endorsement.
“Based on those figures, yes, I think that I mean the mix has shifted,” he said.
“I think we also should judge it over an extended period of time, and a housing market that’s growing at double digits after the growth that we’ve seen over multiple decades is not sustainable.”
Despite weaker overall application demand, Comyn said CBA had recorded stronger retail construction lending over the latest six-month period.
“On the retail lending side, construction loans to individuals who might be building their own home, we’re seeing about a 25 per cent increase in construction loans in the last six months versus the previous consecutive six-month period,” he said.
[Related: Broker mortgage share rising at CBA despite proprietary push]
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make The Adviser a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add The Adviser as a preferred news source.