You have 0 free articles left this month.
Borrower

Greens weigh CGT roadblock as Chalmers rejects rival plan

•7 min read
Share this article on:

The federal government’s tax overhaul faces a summer showdown as the Greens weigh a rival CGT model.

The Greens are considering a Senate inquiry that could stall the Albanese government’s remaining capital gains tax (CGT) legislation, with the party’s Treasury spokesman Nick McKim flagging support for examining an alternative proposed by independent MP Allegra Spender.

The government wants its remaining budget bills through the Senate by the end of next week, but McKim indicated that its political timetable would not determine the Greens’ approach.

Instead, he said the party was considering referring the legislation to a Senate committee for scrutiny over summer, including examination of Spender’s proposal to retain a reduced CGT discount for active assets.

 
 

With the new regime scheduled to commence on 1 July 2027, that would frustrate the government’s preferred passage timetable.

McKim confirmed that he had discussed the alternative with Spender, the independent member for Wentworth, and said the party was assessing its merits.

“I’ve spoken to Allegra about those proposals. They’re very interesting proposals, and we’re having a look at those now,” he said.

He also welcomed the prospect of a broader inquiry examining the competing approaches before Parliament returns next year.

“And we’re very happy if that bill does get sent to an inquiry over the summer; very happy to have the inquiry examine the Spender suggestions along with a range of other matters,” he said.

Rival model draws a line between business and property

The dispute follows Labor’s May budget decision to replace the longstanding 50 per cent CGT discount with cost-base indexation and introduce a minimum 30 per cent tax rate on capital gains.

Rather than excluding half an eligible gain from tax, indexation adjusts an asset’s cost base for inflation before the taxable gain is calculated.

Following pressure from small businesses, the government developed the innovative business CGT concession, or IBCC, to provide different treatment for qualifying businesses.

Access requires businesses to satisfy three tests, including an assessment of whether they are innovative.

Spender’s plan meanwhile would abolish that concession and instead apply a flat 40 per cent discount to active assets, including business assets and shares.

Passive assets, including investment property, would remain subject to indexation, while the proposed 30 per cent minimum rate would remain.

Spender argued that a broader concession would recognise commercial risk without making tax treatment depend on whether a business qualified as innovative.

“It is a huge risk to start, back and grow a business. We need a tax system that rewards that, and is simple and treats all businesses the same, whether you are a tech business or a design house,” Spender said.

“The PM and treasurer have promised to listen to business. This is the moment.”

Spender’s proposal has attracted widespread support from business groups and economists.

Chalmers warns alternative could create fresh problems

Treasurer Jim Chalmers pushed back against Spender’s model at the Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s annual forum in Sydney on Tuesday, 17 November.

He said he had not been negotiating with the Greens about adopting her CGT proposal and maintained that the government had substantive objections.

“I have a lot of respect for Allegra and the contribution that she makes, but there are important reasons why I don’t think the model that she’s put forward is the right model,” Chalmers said.

“In its view, it’s more likely to be more complex. It could lead to higher taxes on some innovative startups, and we think that there are more integrity issues with what has been proposed, and I say all of that respectfully.”

Opposition Leader Angus Taylor has separately reaffirmed that the Coalition would oppose the budget tax increases and repeal them if elected.

Trust tax negotiations face a separate sticking point

The government is also confronting the Greens’ demands over its proposed minimum 30 per cent tax rate on trusts.

McKim said securing support would require discussions about preventing trusts from claiming deductions for payments such as private school donations.

He argued that the arrangements could provide tax benefits unavailable to wage earners.

“There is no adequate rationale for a trust to be able to claim a tax benefit for something like a donation to a private school or to a cult like the Exclusive Brethren that an individual person who’s a wage earner does not have access to,” he said.

Chalmers acknowledged negotiations with the Greens over the trust measures but said the government had not shifted on exemptions, including those concerning religious schools and sporting groups.

“I’m obviously aware of some of the proposals that they put to us publicly and privately, and we’re in discussions with the Greens about that, but we haven’t changed our position on the exemptions in the arrangements that we announced earlier in the year,” he said.

“Our objectives are clear: no one party controls the Senate on its own, and so these discussions that we have with the crossbench and with others are just a necessary part of trying to get difficult legislation through the upper house.”

Business compliance changes accompany savings push

Alongside the tax negotiations, Chalmers outlined work on a second regulation-reduction package ahead of the 2027 budget, with business tax administration among its priorities.

He said consultation with businesses and investors was already underway and would continue as the package developed.

“We’ve already begun engaging the business and investor community seeking ideas, and this will continue over the coming months,” said Chalmers.

“Reducing business tax compliance costs is one priority example.”

He said the government would immediately consult on pre-filling contractor income for sole traders, a measure Chalmers estimated could eliminate 400,000 hours of paperwork and save $37 million annually.

Chalmers also revealed the government would examine replacing subjective assessments of fringe benefits worth less than $300 with a per-employee annual threshold.

While regulatory changes are being developed for next year’s budget, Chalmers said savings would dominate December’s Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook.

“We’re not complacent about inflation, the budget or the structural and global challenges that are weighing on our economy. That’s why next month’s mid-year budget update will include a substantial savings package,” Chalmers said.

Chalmers said the update would balance restraint against the risk of excessive spending reductions, promising it would “cut enough, but not too much”.

“Savings will be the main focus, for two reasons: First, because of the intensifying spending pressures coming at us, including higher debt interest, rising costs of essential services, and other unavoidable spends and variations,” he said.

He argued that the package, alongside productivity measures and reduced red tape, would help contain inflation while preserving economic growth.

“It will help ease immediate capacity pressures without putting growth at risk, and make room for the responsible cost-of-living relief we’ve been rolling out without adding to price pressures,” he said.

[Related: Trust changes to smash SMEs and supply, warn associations]

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make The Adviser a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add The Adviser as a preferred news source.

the adviser combined  x    b wpb