Industry heavyweights have warned that the federal government’s trust changes could squeeze family businesses, derail developments, and push construction costs higher.
Five national business and housing associations have urged federal senators to reject the government’s proposed discretionary trust tax changes in their current form, warning they would hurt small family businesses and obstruct housing construction.
The Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI), Council of Small Business Organisations Australia (COSBOA), Housing Industry Association (HIA), Master Builders Australia, and Property Council of Australia issued the appeal in an open letter to every senator on Sunday (15 November).
Their intervention follows the Senate economics legislation committee’s recommendation that the legislation pass without the changes industry had sought.
The organisations warned senators that the proposal’s consequences would extend beyond business owners to families and the housing market.
“In the final sitting weeks of the year, you will be asked to vote on legislation that risks hurting hundreds of thousands of small family businesses and the families who run them, while placing further pressure on Australia’s housing supply when we can least afford it,” the letter said.
Family businesses face a difficult choice
Under the proposal, trustees would pay a minimum 30 per cent tax on discretionary trusts’ taxable income for income years beginning on or after 1 July 2028.
Non-corporate beneficiaries would receive non-refundable credits for tax paid by the trustee.
Discretionary trusts allow trustees to determine annually how income is allocated among beneficiaries, with the government arguing that the changes would curb tax-planning advantages, including income splitting between family members on different marginal rates.
However, the associations described discretionary trusts as “widely misunderstood” as a vehicle for the wealthy, pointing to approximately 350,000 small family businesses using them.
The associations stressed that the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) confirmed during committee hearings that roughly 99 per cent of discretionary trusts reporting business income in 2023–24 were classified as micro or small businesses.
“They are builders, tradies, café owners, retailers and small developers who use trusts to manage risk, support succession planning and manage unpredictable income. These arrangements have been lawful for decades,” the associations said.
Affected owners could retain their structures and pay the minimum tax, restructure, or elect to fix distributions.
A three-year rollover window, running from 1 July 2027 to 30 June 2030, would provide relief from income tax and capital gains tax (CGT) arising from eligible restructures into companies or fixed trusts, while state stamp duty would remain outside that relief.
Alternatively, qualifying trusts could become excluded election trusts, nominating beneficiaries and fixing their respective shares of income and capital.
The groups argued that each route would impose an unacceptable trade-off, diverting resources from investment into tax payments, restructuring or compliance.
“Small business can’t afford this – neither can an economy that needs small businesses and family builders prioritising investment. For small businesses and family builders, none of these is a real choice,” the letter said.
“Imposing a huge new tax on small business will obviously hurt their ability to operate, provide jobs, and survive. It runs completely counter to the government’s expressed desire that the private sector drive new growth in the economy.”
Construction costs and projects under pressure
The associations also warned that changing established business structures would create particular difficulties for family builders, adding to the challenge of expanding housing delivery.
“This is also a housing issue. Discretionary trusts are one of the most common ways family-owned building businesses are structured,” the associations said.
“As drafted, the Bill will increase compliance costs, reduce flexibility and undermine the risk management approaches many builders rely on.”
They further argued that the financial consequences would not remain confined to business balance sheets, with customers ultimately exposed to higher costs.
“As these reforms increase construction costs through restructuring, compliance and administration expenses, and reduced business returns, builders will ultimately have little choice but to pass these costs on to clients and homeowners,” the letter said.
The letter also cited survey findings suggesting that the policy could alter development decisions, including whether some projects proceed.
“A recent survey found 60 per cent of small and medium residential and commercial developers expect this policy will affect the timing or viability of their projects. Of those, 37 per cent said one or more projects would be cancelled altogether,” the associations said.
“At a time when new supply is the only long-term fix for Australia’s housing shortage, we need to let builders get on with the job, not add more hurdles and disincentives.”
Broker structures caught in wider tax debate
Mortgage broking businesses operating through discretionary trusts also face potential disruption, with the Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia (MFAA) having previously warned that restructuring could require changes to lender accreditations and licensing arrangements.
In its September Treasury submission on the exposure draft, the MFAA acknowledged that the excluded election trust regime and expanded fixed-trust definition offered improvements yet warned that genuine businesses could still face either reduced flexibility or expensive restructuring.
The measures sit within the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026 and the Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026.
The package also advances the second tranche of the government’s CGT and negative gearing changes.
The bills cleared the House of Representatives on 29 October, and following hearings on 5 and 6 November, the Senate committee recommended passage on 13 November.
With the Coalition opposed to the bill, Labor requires the Greens support for the changes to pass the Senate.
The Australian Financial Review reported last week that the Greens were pushing for the almost 1 million discretionary trust beneficiaries to be publicly identified in exchange for backing the tax.
Greens Treasury spokesman Nick McKim described discretionary trusts as “one of the ways wealthy people minimise their tax”.
The government is reportedly targeting a Senate vote in November’s third week, with eight sitting days remaining this year.
[Related: Discretionary trust changes to shrink housing pipeline]
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make The Adviser a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add The Adviser as a preferred news source.