You have 0 free articles left this month.
Lender

Banks ramp up cashback war as new lending slumps

•6 min read
Share this article on:

Lenders are throwing thousands at refinancing borrowers as a sharp mortgage downturn intensifies competition for customers.

Australian banks and mutual lenders are stepping up their fight for refinancing customers, offering cashback incentives worth up to $4,000 as rising interest rates and collapsing demand for new home loans reshape the lending market.

The renewed competition comes as borrowers look to reduce their mortgage repayments following five Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) interest rate increases this year, while lenders seek to protect market share against a steep decline in property purchase activity.

The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) recently revealed that the number of new housing loan commitments plunged 15 per cent in the September quarter, while their total value fell 15.5 per cent.

 
 

Investor lending was particularly hard hit, with commitments falling 30.6 per cent over the quarter and 38.5 per cent annually, while owner-occupier commitments declined 5.3 per cent.

Against this backdrop, lenders have increasingly turned to refinancing incentives, retention payments and competitive repricing to attract borrowers from rivals or prevent existing customers from leaving.

Cashback offers commonly range between $1,000 and $4,000, with eligibility typically determined by minimum loan sizes, loan-to-value ratios (LVRs) and other lending criteria.

IMB Bank is among the lenders offering the largest incentives, providing a $4,000 cashback to eligible borrowers refinancing loans of $750,000 or more from another institution.

The mutual bank is also offering $3,000 for loans between $500,000 and $749,999, and $2,000 for loans between $250,000 and $499,999.

Greater Bank is offering $3,000 for eligible home loans of at least $500,000, alongside a $2,500 incentive for loans between $250,000 and $499,999.

BankVic is targeting eligible members with cashbacks of up to $4,000 for police officers and $3,000 for other qualifying members, including those from the health, emergency services and government sectors, on loans of at least $350,000.

Meanwhile, ME Bank is offering $3,000 for eligible refinances of at least $700,000, while Newcastle Permanent has incentives reaching $3,000 and Bank of Queensland (BOQ) is offering $2,000 on qualifying refinancing loans.

Most offers require an LVR of 80 per cent or less, with additional lender-specific conditions.

Although ANZ is offering a $3,000 cashback to eligible first home buyers (FHB), its incentive does not extend to refinancing customers.

The resurgence contrasts with the approach taken by the major banks, including the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), National Australia Bank (NAB) and Westpac, which largely withdrew broad cashback campaigns in 2023 amid concerns about profitability.

However, competition extends beyond lump-sum payments, with lenders sharpening front-book rates, repricing existing mortgages, waiving fees and improving application turnaround times to attract and retain customers.

Refinancing takes centre stage as purchases retreat

The intensifying battle reflects a significant change in the composition of mortgage lending, with refinancing accounting for an increasingly important share of activity even as new property purchases weaken.

Borrowers refinanced $41.3 billion in owner-occupier mortgages with external lenders across 67,051 loans during the September quarter, while mortgage brokers arranged 77.6 per cent of refinanced home loans.

Figures from mortgage technology platform Quickli suggest refinances now represent approximately one-third of broker deals, compared with around one-quarter a year earlier.

Investor transactions, meanwhile, account for just over one-quarter of deals, while average debt-to-income ratios among approved borrowers have fallen approximately 7 per cent over the year.

Yellow Brick Road home loans executive chairman Mark Bouris recently offered an even more confronting assessment, warning that refinancing was sustaining mortgage activity at his business as demand for property purchases evaporated.

Speaking at the launch of the Get Ahead campaign in Sydney on 11 November, Bouris revealed that mortgages written through the aggregation group had fallen 28 per cent since March.

In February and March, investors accounted for 32 per cent of the group's borrowers, while 38 per cent were purchasing owner-occupied homes.

However, Bouris said those proportions had since collapsed to just 3 per cent each, leaving refinancing responsible for the overwhelming majority of activity.

“The flow of new loans is actually close to zero,” Bouris said.

“It’s mostly just refinancing; any new lending virtually doesn’t exist. This will be the longest downturn in our history. I think Jim Chalmers has put himself in a trap.”

Cashback competition raises concerns over channel fairness

The intensifying contest for refinancing customers has also prompted warnings about lenders prioritising short-term market share at the expense of established distribution relationships.

Finance Brokers Association of Australasia (FBAA) chief executive Leo Gagic recently cautioned that while cashback incentives could encourage competition and benefit borrowers, their effectiveness depended on how consistently lenders made them available across origination channels.

“The issue is not the incentive itself, but ensuring competition occurs in a manner that supports consumer choice and treats all origination channels fairly,” he said.

“Short-term market share gains should not come at the expense of long-term channel relationships that are fundamental to a competitive and sustainable lending market.”

He added that the principal concern arose when lenders reserved incentives for particular distribution channels or offered materially different terms to borrowers approaching them directly compared with those using brokers.

“The challenge is not whether lenders offer incentives, but how they do so. When offers are only available through selected origination channels, or one channel receives a materially different proposition, the potential for channel conflict increases,” Gagic said.

Refinancing demand grows despite borrower inertia

Further evidence of the changing market has emerged from Mortgage Choice’s latest Home Loan Report, which revealed refinancing submissions increased 8 per cent nationally over the year.

However, despite the growing appetite for refinancing, Mortgage Choice found that only two in five mortgage holders had actively reviewed their home loan over the preceding 12 months.

Its research also revealed significant differences in borrowers' perceptions of their available options depending on how they approached the refinancing process.

Among borrowers who engaged a broker to review their mortgage, 75 per cent believed doing so provided greater choice, while 51 per cent of those who approached their lender directly felt their options were limited.

Although two-thirds of mortgage holders expressed confidence in their ability to switch lenders, 55 per cent said they would feel more confident doing so with the assistance of a broker.

[Related: Brokers urged to diversify as mortgage market cools]

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make The Adviser a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add The Adviser as a preferred news source.

nab westpac anz cna macquarie big five banks ta kr tav