the adviser logo

Hayne’s remuneration recommendations ‘contradictory’

by Tas Bindi5 minute read
Siobhan Hayden

The royal commission’s final recommendations on the remuneration of brokers and bank executives are “contradictory”, an industry leader has argued.

Speaking to The Adviser, HashChing COO Siobhan Hayden pointed out that, on the one hand, commissioner Kenneth Hayne advocated for the Banking Executive Accountability Regime, under which authorised deposit-taking institutions are expected to establish a remuneration policy requiring that a portion of executives’ variable remuneration be deferred for a minimum of four years and reduced commensurate with any failure to meet their obligations to act in the best interests of customers.

To continue reading the rest of this article, create a free account
Already have an account? Sign in

On the other hand, the royal commission recommended that the payment of trailing commission – where a portion of the broker’s commission is paid incrementally over three or four years – be banned initially, with the payment of upfront commissions to also be forbidden in due course and replaced with a borrower-pays broker remuneration model.

“The dichotomy, from my perspective, is that throughout the same royal commission, he advocated for the Banking Executive Accountability Regime, which in parallel says, as an executive, we won't pay you all your bonus in your first year, we will make sure your decisions as an executive will deliver good outcomes for the bank or the financial institution, and we will pay those over three to four years,” Ms Hayden said.


“In the same conversation, [the royal commission is] saying that’s how brokers are remunerated, but they will unravel that. So, it’s completely contradictory.”

The HashChing COO recalled a broker writing that “it’s so bad, it’s good” following the release of the final royal commission report.

She described this as a “great adage” because the report was “so bad to our industry that we mobilised, and we were quick to engage with MPs”.

“We’ve been successful in clarifying our model,” Ms Hayden said.

“When commissioner Hayne was looking at unravelling what he viewed as conflicted remuneration, the challenge with any change is [whether] you [are] moving to something better.

“Sometimes it’s easy to say, ‘Well, that’s not ideal, but we’ll move to X’ without actually considering the impact of the change.”

Both major political parties were firm in their initial statements that they would be implementing commissioner Hayne’s 76 recommendations, but have since backpedalled.

Following widespread campaigning and lobbying by the broking industry, the Liberal Party announced that, if re-elected, it would look at reviewing the impacts of removing trail in three years’ time rather than abolishing it next year as originally announced, while the Labor Party proposed that lenders instead pay brokers a standardised upfront commission as a proportion of the loan amount. It suggested that commissions be capped at a fixed rate of 1.1 per cent.

[Related: ]

Hayne’s remuneration recommendations ‘contradictory’
siobhan hayden ta
TheAdviser logo
siobhan hayden ta

Tas Bindi

Tas Bindi


Tas Bindi is the features editor for The Adviser magazine. 


You need to be a member to post comments. Register for free today


Glen Lees

Connective announces record settlement figures

Mortgage aggregator Connective has revealed that its brokers settled a record $95.5 billion across its residential,...

charles grover outfund ta zgvq5o

New SME lender launches into broker channel

A new fintech lender, Outfund, is ramping up for growth through the broker channel after having completed a capital...

david bailey afg ta l8ozkr

AFG’s bottom line hit by Volt closure

The ASX-listed company, Australian Finance Group Ltd (ASX: AFG) has confirmed it is set to deliver “strong...

Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more