You have 0 free articles left this month.
Broker

Brokers at the crossroads: When the market slows, strategy matters

•7 min read
Share this article on:

With new lending volumes falling sharply and pressure spreading across the property industry, brokers face a difficult question: Is their business structured to survive a prolonged downturn, or are they simply waiting for the market to rescue them? Business Advice Agency principal Phil Rice examines what brokers need to do now.

The numbers have caught up with us.

Anyone writing loans this year didn’t need the Australian Bureau of Statistics to tell them the market was getting tougher. But the latest figures have certainly removed any doubt.

New housing loan commitments fell 15 per cent in the September quarter to 111,878, while their value declined 15.5 per cent to $81.2 billion. These were the largest quarterly falls since the series began in 2002.

 
 

Mark Bouris recently highlighted just how serious the situation has become, reporting that mortgage volumes at Yellow Brick Road had fallen 28 per cent since March, with the flow of new purchase loans approaching zero.

Much of the remaining activity is refinancing.

Some will argue about the reasons. Others will confidently predict when the market will recover. There is never a shortage of experts who can tell us what the market will do next, particularly after it has already happened.

But brokers have a more immediate problem.

What happens to your brokerage if the market doesn’t recover for another 12, 18, or even 24 months?

That is the question every brokerage owner should be asking.

Real estate may be showing us what comes next

Mortgage brokers and real estate agents operate in the same ecosystem. When buyers disappear, property transactions slow and referral pipelines inevitably suffer.

Real estate commentator Tom Panos recently highlighted reports that agent numbers in Parramatta and Western Sydney had declined from approximately 1,600 to 1,200 in just nine months.

That’s roughly one in four agents gone.

Real estate agents generally feel a downturn first because their income is directly tied to transactions. Brokers have some protection through recurring trail commissions, but that protection isn’t unlimited.

Trail income can decline as loans discharge, refinance or amortise. Meanwhile, staff, technology, rent, insurance and other operating expenses don’t conveniently reduce themselves because the market is having a bad year.

The uncomfortable reality is that some brokerages will struggle, some will consolidate and others may disappear altogether.

The market doesn’t care how good you were at writing loans last year. It cares whether your business can survive this year.

The next 2 years will require more than good broking skills

Having spent around 30 years in finance and broking, I’ve seen good markets make average businesses look successful.

When inquiries are flowing, settlements are increasing, and commissions are arriving, it is easy to confuse market momentum with business management.

A strong market can hide a multitude of business weaknesses. A downturn has a rather unpleasant habit of exposing every one of them.

The brokers best positioned for the next two years won’t necessarily be those who wrote the most loans during the boom. They’ll be those who understand how to run a commercially sustainable business.

That starts with structure – defined processes, accountable people, reliable financial reporting, and a clear understanding of where tomorrow’s income will come from. Lead generation also needs serious attention. Waiting for the phone to ring or relying on a handful of real estate agents isn’t a growth strategy. Brokers need consistent prospecting, structured referral relationships, effective follow-up and marketing that produces measurable opportunities.

Then there is the existing client database.

For many brokers, their greatest untapped opportunity is sitting inside their own trail book. These are clients who already know them, have previously trusted their advice and may need assistance again. Yet too many brokerages have no structured process for maintaining those relationships.

It is extraordinary how much effort some businesses put into finding a new client while practically inviting their existing clients to refinance with someone else.

Revenue diversification also deserves attention. Asset finance, commercial lending and other appropriate credit services can provide additional opportunities and reduce dependence on residential purchase transactions.

The missing ingredient is often business management

The finance industry does an excellent job of teaching brokers how to write loans, meet compliance obligations and navigate lender policies.

But who teaches them how to build, manage and grow a profitable business?

Through Better Business Coach and our work delivering the FBAA Emerging Broker Academy, we’ve seen firsthand the difference between understanding lending and understanding business.

They are two very different disciplines.

A broker can be technically excellent, genuinely care about their clients and still operate a financially vulnerable business.

This is where professional business coaching may become particularly valuable. An experienced business adviser can help a principal examine their business objectively, identify weaknesses, establish realistic targets, assess growth opportunities and make difficult decisions before cash flow pressures remove their options.

Hope has never appeared as an asset on a balance sheet.

Thinking ‘outside the box’

These challenges were precisely what led us to invest in the development of Emerald Edge for the broker community.

We wanted to address the business side of broking. Emerald Edge is an advanced, AI-powered broker business management platform designed to sit in front of a broker’s existing aggregator system, managing the day-to-day business activities that generate, nurture and retain clients while providing the knowledge and levers for business growth.

There was another consideration behind its development.

For many brokers, the trail book is their principal saleable asset. Yet a brokerage with established systems, documented processes, transferable client relationships and a business model that can operate beyond its owner has the potential to offer a buyer considerably more.

That is why Emerald Edge was designed to remain independent of the aggregator’s platform. If a broker changes aggregators, their front-end business management system can remain in place while the necessary back-end arrangements are transitioned, providing a smoother and uninterrupted transition.

The objective is to help brokers build a structured, resilient, more independent and potentially saleable business asset that complements the trail book.

The market will eventually recover. Will your business?

Markets move in cycles. Lending activity will eventually improve, although nobody can reliably predict when or how quickly.

The next 24 months may be challenging, but they also present an opportunity to address weaknesses that were probably there long before the market slowed.

For brokers prepared to make changes, the objective shouldn’t simply be survival.

It should be to emerge with a more profitable, efficient, independent and valuable business.

My advice is straightforward: examine your brokerage now. Understand your financial position, strengthen your lead generation, protect your existing clients, establish proper business systems and seek experienced guidance where you need it.

Because when the market turns, the brokers who have built real businesses won’t need to wait for the market to save them. They’ll already be positioned to take advantage of it.

Phil Rice is principal of Business Advice Agency, founder of Emerald Edge and Better Business Coach, an Australian Credit Licence holder and a Certified Professional Business Advisor.

He has approximately 30 years of experience in the finance and broking industry.

References

Australian Bureau of Statistics, Lending Indicators, September Quarter 2026, released 11 November 2026.
Broker Daily, Bouris reveals flow of new loans ’close to zero’ amid lending collapse, 13 November 2026.
Tom Panos, 1 in 4 agents have left the market, Real Estate Market Wrap, LinkedIn, 2026.
Emerald Edge, Broker Business Growth & Value

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make The Adviser a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add The Adviser as a preferred news source.

phil rice   ta dk vex