You have 0 free articles left this month.
Borrower

RBA board members concerned economy on precipice of ‘sharper’ downturn

•7 min read
Share this article on:

It has been revealed that three members of the RBA’s Monetary Policy Board voted against November’s increase over concerns that the economy could be close to a “sharper” downturn.

The three members of the Reserve Bank of Australia’s (RBA) nine-person Monetary Policy Board (MPB) who opposed lifting the cash rate to an 18-year high of 4.85 per cent in November warned that the economy may be close to a “materially sharper downturn”, according to minutes released on Tuesday (17 November).

The minutes revealed that the majority of the board feared that leaving rates unchanged would make inflation more difficult to tame, while the dissenters wanted more time to see how much the four earlier increases had already slowed the economy.

The minutes noted that the three members who favoured holding at 4.60 per cent “placed somewhat less weight than the other members on the upside risks to inflation and somewhat more weight on the downside risks to economic growth”.

 
 

Their concern went beyond the timing of another increase, with the group viewing a risk that the slowdown was on the verge of gathering pace.

“These members expressed their concern that the economy might be near the point of entering a materially sharper downturn and pointed to the costs in terms of unemployment,” the minutes said.

Housing was a key reason the dissenting members believed the slowdown could prove deeper than forecast.

While the RBA’s forecasts already predicted that fewer property transactions would weigh on activity, the board members discussed whether the significant decline in turnover could have a more substantial effect on slowing the economy.

Why 6 members still voted to raise rates

However, the majority of members saw a different danger in waiting and noted that with inflation risks still tilted upwards, a cash rate of 4.60 per cent “was not clearly sufficient to address these risks and return the economy to balance”.

“In particular, they judged the risks of unintentionally leaving monetary policy insufficiently restrictive (potentially allowing medium- to long-term inflation expectations to rise) currently to outweigh the probability associated with unintentionally setting monetary policy too tight (potentially leading to a faster or greater easing in labour market capacity pressures),” the minutes said.

Bullock says the inflation problem predates the oil shock

Speaking at the Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s (ASIC) annual forum in Sydney on Tuesday, RBA governor Michele Bullock said that rising oil prices had made inflation worse but were not the reason the bank began tightening.

“One thing I wanted to make extremely clear is that, it’s not just a response to oil prices. We already had inflation above target, in the latter half of last year and early this year, and we’d already started raising interest rates before, the Middle East conflict started and oil prices started to rise,” Bullock said.

Bullock distinguished between an oil supply shock the RBA could not fix and excess demand in Australia that higher rates could restrain.

“It’s quite true that interest rates do not address that issue. But what we can do is, with interest rates, we can decrease demand and ease the pressure, which is coming from excess demand on the economy. That’s what the interest rate rises are designed to do,” she said.

She also said conversations with businesses were yielding early signs that some might be adjusting to higher inflation, a shift that could make it harder to restore price stability.

“We’re getting just these little inklings from our liaison program when we talk to businesses that they’re thinking, ‘you know what, maybe three, 3.5 per cent is the new normal for inflation’,” she said.

“If that gets ingrained in people’s thinking, in businesses thinking and consumers and households thinking that, it’s going to be much harder to bring inflation back down to target.”

Asked about household budgets after five rate rises, Bullock acknowledged that some mortgage holders were struggling, but singled out low-income renters as particularly vulnerable to persistent inflation.

“I actually think that the average Australian household budget is not where we should be worrying. It’s the people who are struggling towards the bottom end. And they’re typically renters, and they’re typically on low incomes,” Bullock said.

CBA and ANZ see a high bar for another hike

The Commonwealth Bank of Australia’s (CBA) head of Australian economics, Belinda Allen, said the minutes showed a shift in the board’s thinking about domestic capacity and how high rates needed to go.

She added that the arguments for holding offered a clearer guide to what it would take to raise rates again.

“The case to hold provided some new insights and show the hurdles to hike again,” Allen said.

“The argument to hold was driven by timing given recent hikes were still working their way through the economy.

“A second case to hold was concerns around downside risks to growth given recent increases in unemployment, the downturn in the housing market and changing sentiment around data centres.”

Allen described the data since the meeting as mixed, noting weak consumer and business sentiment and continued cooling in housing.

She said a stronger-than-expected inflation reading was the main risk to CBA’s forecast for rates to remain on hold.

“We continue to see the RBA on hold from here unless inflation surprises to the upside. Recent data highlight that the economic cycle is turning,” Allen said.

“December is unlikely to be a live meeting given the proximity to rate hikes. Instead the 7–8 February meeting will be the next most likely time for the RBA to consider a cash rate hike.”

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group’s (ANZ) head of Australian economics, Adam Boyton, said the split vote was itself a sign of how uncertain the outlook for the economy and interest rates had become.

“That should not be surprising, given that uncertainty increases toward the end of a cycle and that a reasonable degree of uncertainty was already reflected in the 6-3 split vote at that meeting,” he said.

Boyton said ANZ expected a strong October inflation reading, but that the bank still believed November’s increase as more likely than not to be the last of the cycle.

“We continue to view the cash rate as having peaked at 4.85 per cent. That said, and as we observed in our October CPI preview yesterday, the next inflation print is likely to be uncomfortably high and a further tightening in monetary policy cannot be completely ruled out,” he said.

“Of course, with the tightening having occurred irrespective, those members who voted against raising the official cash rate would now seem very unlikely to support a near-term increase (absent clearly compelling data).”

[Related: Westpac more convinced rates have peaked as economy weakens]

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make The Adviser a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add The Adviser as a preferred news source.

michele bullock rba ta vymdde