Methodology

Overview

How we judge

The Commercial Finance Awards employ a multi-phase, blind-scored judging process overseen by an independent panel of senior industry figures. Each submission is evaluated against a standardised rubric specific to its category, ensuring every entry is judged fairly and consistently.

The methodology was developed in consultation with industry bodies and experienced commercial finance professionals to ensure it captures the full breadth of excellence in the sector – from individual broker performance to organisational leadership and innovation.

The process

Three judging phases

01.

Eligibility verification

All submissions are reviewed for completeness and compliance with category-specific eligibility criteria. Incomplete submissions or those not meeting threshold requirements are removed before scoring begins. This ensures every entry that proceeds to judging is evaluated on merit alone.

02.

Independent scoring

Each submission is assigned to multiple judges who score it independently against the category rubric. Judges do not confer during this phase. Scoring is conducted blind, so judges see the submission content but not identifying information such as names, companies, or brands, where practicable.

03.

Panel deliberation and final determination

The full judging panel convenes to review aggregated scores, discuss any significant discrepancies between judges, and finalise the determination of finalists and winners. In the event of a tied score, the panel chair casts the deciding vote. All decisions of the judging panel are final and no correspondence will be entered into.

Scoring

Scoring framework

Each submission is scored against four weighted criteria. The maximum possible score is 100 points.

30%

Business performance and growth

Quantitative evidence of business growth, including settlement volumes, loan book growth, revenue trends, market share expansion, and client acquisition.

30%

Client outcomes and service excellence

Demonstrated commitment to client service, as evidenced by client testimonials, retention rates, net promoter scores, and case studies showing positive client impact.

25%

Industry contribution and leadership

Evidence of contribution to the broader commercial finance industry through advocacy, mentoring, education, association involvement, or thought leadership.

15%

Innovation and best practice

Adoption of innovative practices, technology, or business models that advance the standard of commercial finance broking.

Judging panel

An independent panel

The 2026 judging panel will be announced prior to submissions opening. Panel members are selected for their seniority, impartiality, and deep knowledge of the commercial finance landscape. Judges are required to declare any conflicts of interest and recuse themselves from evaluating submissions where a conflict exists.

Momentum Media employees, event sponsors, and partners are not eligible to serve as judges and have no influence over scoring outcomes.

Meet the judges

View categories

Judging methodology